As a cartographer, occasional “map-artist”, AND a photographer, I’ve been following the NFT art trend for a while now and have been wondering when more map projects would show up.

I’ll say from the start that I am definitely in the NFTs are a racket camp… so take this all with a huge dose of sodium. My first thought here is that the biggest issues with NFTs are not the ones most people have been talking about, specifically the energy and environmental costs. A move from Proof-of-work to Prof-of-stake in my opinion is a minimal improvement to the risks and downsides of selling and buying NFTs. The market is awash in scams, “toxic positivity”, and outright theft of many kinds. The best explainer I’ve found on all of this is Dan Olson’s video “Line Goes Up” (https://youtu.be/YQ_xWvX1n9g). Anyone even considering entering the NFT market should watch it, but beware it’s 2 hours long!

As someone who sells creative work online, I see the appeal of NFTs to small artists. The promise of NFTs is valid and potentially positive, but the current reality is very few smaller or unique art projects are making any headway, the market mostly exists in a speculative state right now. The biggest earners appear to be sequential-generative “art” projects like the Board Ape Yacht Club. Or digital artists who already command large followings through social media to whom they can market directly.

About the maps themselves, I like the idea of applying outside domain influences and aesthetics to map making. I am decidedly not a traditionalist in cartographic terms! So experimental film influences in maps sounds awesome to me. But, and I apologize for the frankness of this, on the surface this project feels a lot like another sequential-generative NFT project, just with map data. I know there are many real-world examples of art in series or collections (digital as well). I’m not sure what the line is between creating a legitimate expressive art series and what many sequential NFTs projects are doing, I think in some ways NFTs have blurred these lines extremely. I’d be interested to see how this series develops though. And I definitely hope you're able to make the NFT mechanism work for map-art sales!

Best,
David



David Medeiros

Geospatial Reference & Instruction Specialist

Stanford Geospatial Center

650.561.5294

@mapbliss


SGC website: gis.stanford.edu

GIS cartography: bit.ly/giscart<http://bit.ly/giscart><http://bit.ly/giscart>

GIS email list: bit.ly/GISlist



Olá de Lisboa,

At some point, someone may inquire of you about maps and non-fungible tokens, or NFTs. I've searched the archives of the list and the only use of "NFT" is from a 2002 listing of maps for sale where NFT is an abbreviation for "Not For Tourists" (!). "fungible" is not (yet) in the archives at all. So my email will be on a more contemporary topic than most.

(I have been on MAPS-L for decades, mostly as a lurker, but I appreciate the occasional inquiries about "what's new?" and I hope you'll indulge my writing today about something that's new even if puzzling.)

I'm in the middle of a two month (March & April) international artist residency at Hangar: Centro de Investigação Artística. I'm working on three projects, all related to digital cartography, and I've started issuing the first one as a sequence of animated, monochromatic maps, "minting" & "swapping" them on the Tezos blockchain. Tezos is a "proof-of-stake" rather than "proof-of-work" blockchain, the energy costs of the former not being as inconceivable & inappropriate as the latter, and the resilient Hic Et Nunc marketplace that's evolved around that cryptocurrency is allegedly one of the most artist-friendly. This is all new to me and I likely share many of your suspicions & cynicisms. I will recommend Brian Frye's entertaining and thought-provoking presentation to you, especially for his observations on how NFTs relate to provenance: https://youtu.be/c7N1nX7VmEY

There are a few art historical influences that nourished my sequences – 16mm experimental flicker films, of which Paul Sharits is the most closely-aligned practitioner; op art (e.g., Bridget Riley); light and space art (e.g., James Turrell, Carlos Cruz-Diez); concrete poetry and the constrained wordplay of the Oulipo. I've also lifted ideas and inspiration from painters Patrick Caulfield, Michael Craig-Martin, and Ed Ruscha. You may recall that Daniel P. Huffman, a cartographer with strong ties to NACIS, issued a call for monochrome maps in 2018. These sequences can be thought of as a "long tail" response to that call.

Each sequence is a numbered "If Map", e.g, "If Map 9.5 (Monochrome: Honeydew)", and the whole cycle, which will be compiled and released in a slightly different format for gallery installation/theatrical projection, will be "If Map #9" with a longer title yet TBD. The plan is to release a new sequence every two days for the remainder of April, populating the gallery at https://www.hicetnunc.xyz/erictheise

I advise that these involve strobing so if flashing light causes you headaches or worse please be forewarned.

I'll add that the experimental filmmaker, even when working digitally but especially when working with analog small gauge film (8mm, Super8, 16mm), faces a great many expenses in production (filmstock, equipment, lab work, time) and distribution (e.g., festival entry fees), and often receives no rental income even when their film is accepted for exhibition at a festival or microcinema. In light of these dismal & long-standing circumstances the possibilities of the NFT art marketplace are appealing, even irresistible: a new audience, geographically dispersed, allegedly with a budget for acquiring art (or simply provenance), plus enforced resale royalties.

If you've read this far, thank you. This is the most I've written and revealed about the project in one place. My posts to social media have been terser, more mysterious & stingy with information, or perhaps going into greater detail about one facet. I still haven't told you everything you might want to know and I welcome your feedback or questions, although I may not answer them until more of the sequences in the cycle have been released.

Obrigado, Eric

P.S. I invite you to follow day-to-day progress on my Instagram or other social media feeds, I'm not hard to find. Wordier but far-less frequent updates go out over my Mailchimp list, https://erictheise.com/mailing-list/<http://erictheise.com/mailing-list/>