The paper in question is available online at
http://www.journals.royalsoc.ac.uk/content/7vn5p9c3wen58bvy/
(see link therein for full text version in PDF format).
I am, however, extremely surprised that anyone would seek to criticize
the contents of a paper they claim to have never read.
Phil Jeffrey
Princeton, NJ
On 5/29/07, rsheil <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
[much text omitted]
>
> Mark,
> I haven't read the original paper but am basing my criticism of the
> extinction claims based on dozens (actually hundreds) of reports eminating
> from the above sources citing your paper. Does your paper, or does it not,
> predict extinction at or near 2010 for rufa Red Knot?
[more text omitted]