I have read the article regarding the proposed bill which would protect the
Texas State Shell.  It is preposterous to consider that this species needs
protection because of its use as a food source.  The species may indeed be
declining as are related species off our coast, but I suggest that these
declines are due to changing environment and not the use of the species as a
food source.  Shrimpers typically do not retain the shells that are part of
their bycatch.  Due to changing regulations, many shrimp boat captains require
that all shells be thrown overboard.  Their reaction to existing regulations
make it virtually impossible for me to persuade shrimpers to save any shells
for my research in the Northern Gulf of Mexico.  Prior to the passage of
recent regulations, most shrimpers were all to happy to cooperate with
researchers and collectors.   If the state of Texas is really concerned about
this species, the efforts would be better spent allocating money for
researchers within the state to conduct studies to determine why the species
is declining.   Knee jerk reactionary environmental legislation such as this
does more to harm worthy environmental causes than they actually succeed in
accomplishing their desired goals.  I encourage the lawmakers of the state of
Texas to do their homework before enacting such ill-conceived legislation.  If
the facts warrant such legislation, so be it.  If not, as it appears in this
case, it is best that lawmakers leave well enough alone or else spend the
money that is necessary to help ensure the survival of the species.
 
Douglas N. Shelton
Alabama Malacological Research Center
2370-G Hillcrest Road #236
Mobile, AL 36695