I also agree. In all cases where i brought new species to light i always chose a specimen that best emplifies the qualities that sets it apart from comparative species. Most cases this is the best specimen in the lot. Depending on how many specimens are in the study lot i also include designated paratypes to be widely distributed in conjunction with the author. I also have included added topotypes from the original study lot to be dispersed at the author's recommendations as well. In cases where low numbers were apparent i've donated all pieces to be deposited. To length all my activities to get new species properly named have ended up costing me in high expenses and most importantly time. I'll never be rich doing this because the money isn't there in this field i've chosen. I do this out of love of the hobby. Every new species that i've helped bring to light was done totally at my expense with no financial help from any person or institution. On this forum i've taken "pot-shots" indirectly from purist who believe all types belong in institutions. If any individual or museum that wants to foot the bill in the expenses/time it took to bring these species to light, then yes i'll happily turn in the few paratypes that were returned to me. In some cases none were returned, which i have no problems with either. I chose to do what i've done so im ok with that. I hope some of the Conchers out there will realize what it takes nowadays for a species to be named. When i read some of the responces it shows no respect or gratitude at all for the dealers, or advanced collectors, who are instrumental in bringing these new species to our hobby. Chris:( ---------------------------------------------------------------------- [log in to unmask] - a forum for informal discussions on molluscs To leave this list, click on the following web link: http://listserv.uga.edu/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=conch-l&A=1 Type your email address and name in the appropriate box and click leave the list. ----------------------------------------------------------------------